Why “Chicken” on the Bag Doesn’t Mean Chicken in the Bowl

Hey friend,

Well, that was fun, wasn't it? Learning that "complete and balanced" isn't the iron-clad guarantee we thought, but a standard written by the very industry that profits from it.

Lovely little arrangement they have there.

Now, let's talk about the next thing that catches your eye: the big, wholesome words on the bag.

Salmon. Beef. Chicken.

These are the proteins our meat loving dogs are actually built to eat. So when we see them splashed across the packaging, we feel good. We think we understand what's inside.

But is it as murky as "complete and balanced"?

Unfortunately, yes.

I spent ages down a rabbit hole of blogs and books trying to decode these rules. It was a mess, so I went straight to AAFCO's own wording.

And … it's vague in a way only an industry protecting itself could write.

(Spoiler: Comparing dog food to a restaurant order is not the rigorous science you'd hope for when choosing what fuels your dog's life.)

Here's what AAFCO says, and what it actually means for you and your dog.

AAFCO does have strict naming rules.
They just don't apply to the bags of kibble that we have all grown accustomed to feeding our dogs.

The 100 Percent Rule only covers single-ingredient treats like jerky.

The 95 Percent Rule applies mostly to canned food, where "Beef Dog Food" must be at least 95 percent beef (minus water).

Kibble can't qualify for either one.
It physically can't survive production without carbs and binders.
So the strictest naming laws AAFCO has…
don't apply to the bags stacked in the pet food aisle.

Now you enter kibble territory, the numbers collapse faster than Blue chasing a lizard.

There's no 75 percent rule.
No 50 percent rule.
The next stop is twenty-five.

This is where you see words like:

Legally, anything called "Chicken Recipe" only needs to be:

Now here's the part AAFCO actually admits:

They say the 25 percent rule is like ordering a dinner entrée,
where the steak comes with potatoes, veg, salad… all sharing the plate.

Fair enough.

Except… imagine walking into a steakhouse starving, ordering a steak, and your plate arrives 97 percent not steak.

You'd ask to speak to every manager alive.

But that, unfortunately, is exactly how the 25 percent rule works.

And remember… that "25 percent chicken" is calculated before processing removes the water.
By the time it becomes kibble, you might be looking at 6 to 7 percent actual chicken.

Once you see it, you can't unsee it.

If you see the magic word with on a label, like "Dog Food With Chicken", that chicken only has to hit 3 percent. Same for anything else in the name.

AAFCO's own example says "Cynthia's Super Cat Food with Tuna and Rice" only needs 3 percent tuna and 3 percent rice.

Simply put, adding the word with lets a company name an ingredient once it reaches that tiny three-percent threshold.

So you get 3 percent of the meat they're shouting about… and 97 percent surprise.

What's that other 97 percent? Check the label, friend. You're in for a long ride.

If the 95 percent rule is rare, and the 25 percent rule is depressing, the flavor rule is basically the industry shrugging and saying,
"Look, it just has to taste like it."

That's it.
No percentage.
No minimum meat requirement.
Nothing.

A "chicken-flavored" dog food doesn't need meaningful chicken in it at all.
It just needs something—chicken fat, broth, seasoning, "natural chicken flavor"—to give the idea of chicken.
The essence.
The whisper.
The vibe.

As long as the word "flavored" is printed the same size as "chicken," the label is perfectly legal.

So when you see "Chicken-Flavored Dog Food," what you're actually buying is:

A bowl full of whatever…
with a sprinkle of chicken energy.

If the 95 percent rule is steak, the 25 percent rule is a sampler plate.
The flavor rule?
That's a scratch-and-sniff sticker.

Sláinte,
Linda & Blue 🐾

P.S. So we've got our 3% chicken... but what's hiding in the other 97% of that bag? Find out next time - same dog time, same dog channel.

Morning Brew makes business news something you’ll actually look forward to — which is why over 4 million people read it every day.

Sure, the Brew’s take on the news is witty and sharp. But the games? Addictive. You might come for the crosswords and quizzes, but you’ll leave knowing the stories shaping your career and life.

Try Morning Brew’s newsletter for free — and join millions who keep up with the news because they want to, not because they have to.

Try it now

Want to make sure you don't miss the next chapter in our kibble investigation? Subscribe to Dog Blueprints for free and get the truth delivered straight to your inbox.